I was at Sally’s the other day and needed some new black nail polish. I have some old Avon black polish, but it takes approximately 6 coats to reach opacity and is often uneven, has the world’s tiniest brush and is pretty much useless. I’m sure I got it way cheap, but really… was it worth the hassle? I thought not. So while I was at Sally’s I saw all the Finger Paint brand polishes. They are supposed to be made by OPI and come in a wide variety of colors. I believe I got mine for around $4 and the color I chose was Black Expressionism.
What I Liked:
- The handle of the brush is long and tapered. It fit well in my hand and was comfortable to use. The brush is standard, but soft and makes application easy.
- This is the most pigmented polish I have ever seen! The formula is quite thick but not bad thick, and it coated to opacity easily in one coat.
What I HATED!!!!
- I polished my nails at about 5-6 o’clock. At about 7 or so I ate dinner, then washed a few dishes (nothing too crazy where I was scrubbing using a scouring pad or anything, although I did use a scratchy sponge, no different than I ever do though) and by the time I was done with dishes my nails looked like this:

Please enlarge this and take a peek at the hideousness that is Finger Paints. This is one solid coat of FP, and 2 coats of Seche Vite.
UGHHH!!!!!!!!!! This was the worst nail polish I have ever tried!! It will be a LONG time before I try FP again, which is sad because I loved the color density and I like the bottles (although they’re a little tall). Maybe my nails just don’t play well with this brand but it was a major disappointment. 😦
Wow, that Avon polish sounds like a nightmare in every way possible! I agree that despite the cheap price, the hassle doesn’t seem to be worth it.
As for the Fingerpaints polish – I haven’t tried any yet, although I have one (a green, of course). I’m surprised that it ended up looking like that so quickly.
If you’re interested in a black polish, a really great one (at least I think so) is China Glaze Liquid Leather. It’s more a jellyish black, though, not a creme black. So, it’s quite streaky at first, but if you apply 3 coats, it evens out nicely and is super shiny.
Thanks for the recommendation! 🙂 It’s weird about that FP black because some people SWEAR by Finger Paints but mannn they just don’t agree with my nails, I guess. Too bad cuz they do have some cute colors and I LOVE the pigmentation. Oh well… I just got some SH Xtreme Wear and it seems to work much better! 😀 Thank goodness cuz there’s so much layering to be done with a good black. 😉
For sure – black polish is a staple for the nail-polish closet. 😉
Absolutely! And it’s gotta be a good one! 😉